How to A/B test your email campaigns in Poptin
Poptin’s email A/B testing lets you compare two versions of a campaign with a portion of your audience. After the test period, Poptin automatically picks a winner based on opens or clicks and sends it to the rest of your audience.
You can test subject lines, preview text (pretext), sender details, or the email content and design.
Before you start
- Your selected audience must have at least 20 subscribed contacts.
- Verify your From Email and Reply To Email.
- Plan what you want to compare. For a clearer result, change one element at a time, for example two subject lines with the same email design.
- Log in to your Poptin dashboard, click Campaigns under Email, then click Create Campaign.

- Enter your campaign name and click Start.

- On step 1 Audience: Choose who should receive the campaign using Send to, and optionally Don’t send to, then click Next.
Both the test group and the winning email recipients come from this audience.

- On step 2 Setup: Turn on Add A/B Test. You will see Version A and Version B. Fill in these details for each version:
- Email Subject: Up to 100 characters.
- Pretext: Up to 140 characters.
- From Name
- From Email
- Reply to
To rename a version, click the edit icon next to its name, for example “Question subject” and “Benefit subject”. This makes the results easier to read later. To start Version B with the same details as Version A, click Use the same content as Version A, then change only the detail you want to test.

- On step 3 Design: Set up the email for both versions.
- For Version A, select a template and edit it.
- For Version B, click Select Template to choose a different design, or Copy from version A to reuse the same design. Copying is ideal when you are only testing a subject line or sender detail.
- Use Continue Editing to make changes, or Remove to start over.
Once both versions show “You already edited this template”, click Next.
Want to see how the email template editor works? Check our guide here. How to use email campaign editor?

- On step 4 Configure A/B: Test group: Enter a percentage or drag the slider. Poptin splits it equally between Version A and Version B, and the rest of the audience receives the winner. A minimum of 10% is required for the test group. For example, with 100 contacts and a 20% test group:
- Version A: 10 recipients (10%)
- Version B: 10 recipients (10%)
- Winner: 80 recipients (80%)
Winning Criteria:
More opens: Best for comparing subject lines, pretext, or sender names.
More clicks: Best when you want recipients to interact with the email content.
Send winning variation after: Set the test duration in days and hours. The default is 4 hours. Give recipients enough time to open and click before the winner is selected.
If results are inconclusive send: Choose Version A or Version B. Poptin sends this version if there is a tie or no activity, so the campaign never stalls.

- Summary: Review your audience, both versions, test group percentage, winning criteria, and duration. Use Send test email to check each version in your inbox, including the subject line, sender details, links, and layout.

- Click Send to start now, or Schedule to send later. Poptin sends each version to its test group. When the test period ends, it sends the winner to the remaining audience. Contacts who already received a test version are not included again.
- View results: Open View Reports for the campaign to see how each version performed. The winner is marked with a crown.
Updated on: 16/11/2026
Thank you!
